
Issue Date: January 6, 2021From My Window Goodbye Grand Old Lady
Janie Thibodeau Martin
My favorite grand old lady recently left the Menominee River for the last time. In the ultimate loss of dignity, she no longer had the ability to navigate on her own, and her tired old body was hauled out on Dec. 17th by a couple of powerful little tugboats. I am glad I wasn't there to watch her leave, because I would have been sad.
The William H. Donner was a classic Great Lakes bulk freight boat. She was built in Ashtabula, Ohio by The Great Lakes Engineering works, and was intended to replace laker Charles S. Price. Only three years old, the Price sank in a horrific storm in November of 1913 that besides taking her, sunk 18 other ships. The Donner was launched in 1914, making her a venerable 106 when she left us.
It is obvious that the people at Great Lakes Engineering knew how to build a stout ship. The Donner earned her keep hauling material around the lakes for 55 years until she was converted to use as a floating dock equipped with cranes in 1969. She was utilized this way in Milwaukee, tied up and storing scrap metal, then transferring it to other ships for hauling, until she was sold in 1992 to K & K warehousing in Menominee. At that time she became a fixture on the river, facing the Menekaunee lift bridge and very visible on the waterfront.
Her classic laker profile, with the pilothouse forward, marked her as a senior citizen ship even when she arrived. At 524 feet, she looked big if you were up close, but she was tiny compared to the generation of lakers built at 1,000 feet. My family and I always commented on her, never failing to look when we passed over the bridge or walked the lighthouse pier. My Dad taught me to love the lakers, and I in turn, aided by the constant physical presence of the Donner, passed the fascination on to my two little kids.
The Donner couldn't exactly talk, but we knew there had to be fascinating stories of miles under her keel and storms survived. Our imaginations filled in some of the blanks.
Countless ships, many dwarfing her in size, tied alongside her over the years, to be unloaded with the Donner's cranes. She continued to earn her keep and still looked good, if you were far enough away to not see the rust and peeling paint. Her new job was not beneath her, and that sturdy hull kept her afloat. (You also have to commend the people who kept figuring out innovative ways for her to earn money.)
In 2002 her pilothouse was removed, (and can be seen on the north side of the river across from the foundry,) but while she was visually decapitated without that and her smokestack, she kept doing her job, with her superb work ethic. In 2015, she was permanently "retired," and waited five years in the river for this final trip.
She was an antique, a classic, a living piece of history. She was more than a ship's bell and a photo in a museum, she was floating in our river. She sparked many conversations about the lives of sailors, the weather of the Lakes, the rich history of shipping and waterborne commerce the lakes provided; and the fact that Marinette and Menominee owed a lot to their fortunate location on a deep water river mouth.
The Donner, what is left of her, was hauled to Sault Saint Marie, where she will be "recycled," cut up for scrap. Even 100 plus years old, her hull has value, and she can, and should, take pride in her steel heart for the long working life she had. I will miss her each and every time I cross the bridge, and I thank her for the love of lakers she helped inspire in my kids. (In fact, my daughter, who now lives in the international seaport of Seattle, has an "app" on her phone, so that she can identify the merchant ships and the billionaire's yachts she sees. Our son lives in landlocked Oklahoma and must satisfy his ship watching urges with river tug-barges, or when he visits us.)
Lots of people love old trains and old cars. Some cherish steam-powered farm and logging equipment. I love old ships. Well done, William H. Donner.
Note: if you are interested in more of the history and pictures of the Donner in her prime, you can google her name; there is a treasure trove on the internet. I also love and follow the Facebook sites Great Lakes Ship Watchers; Boatnerds; and Ships of the Great Lakes. In addition there is a really informative piece on the Donner available at jayseaarcheology.wordpress.com, written by an author with local knowledge of the twin cities area.
You can reach me for commentary, alternative viewpoints or ideas at this e-mail address: JanieTMartin@gmail.com.

Recent stories, opinions and photos
Issue Date |
Department |
Headline |
03-03-2021 | Sports |
 Cougars & Patriots Bow Out in Sectional Semis

|
03-03-2021 | Sports |
 Maroon Girls Have Strong Defensive Showing

|
03-03-2021 | Sports |
 Peshtigo Varsity Bowlers Headed to State Tourney

|
03-03-2021 | Sports |
 State Boys Basketball Tournament in LaCrosse & Oshkosh This Week

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Takes Down Light Pole

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Crivitz Starting Over In Quest for Police Chief

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Peshtigo School Superintendent Seeks To Partner More With City

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Comprehensive Plan Deadline Topic at Marinette City Council

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Peshtigo School Board To Meet On March 10

|
03-03-2021 | Front Page |
 Barbara Johnston Celebrated 106th Birthday On March 3

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman May Close Rosemont Street Alley

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman School Board To Meet March 8th

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman Utility Meet Monday, March 8

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 7th Annual Equity Craft, Vendor Fair

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 Lady Leprechaun Shopping Day, Gun Show March 13

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 $1000 Scholarship for Athelstane, Silver Cliff Graduating Seniors

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Legion Post 66 To Meet March 6

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Wausaukee Lions Annual Flower Sale

|
03-03-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Wausaukee Blood Drive Nets 51 Pints

|
03-03-2021 | Perspectives |
 From My Window

|
03-03-2021 | Perspectives |
 From our readers

|
03-03-2021 | Perspectives |
 Country Cousin

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Roland C. Abel

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Barton C. Adrian

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Robert J. Barker

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Genevieve T. Cichon

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 William W. Fernstrum

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Phyllis G. Fischer

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Noreen L. Garon

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Terry R. Granger

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Esther Jenquine

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Pieterdina G. Keller

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Thomas R. Kollross

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Mark R. Krzewina

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Lucille M. Lesperance

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Carol L. Philbrick

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Jeanette F. Schahczinski

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Ila R. Sparpana

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Maria M. Waldmeier

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Gale R. Wogsland

|
03-03-2021 | Obituaries |
 Margaret M. Zona

|
02-24-2021 | Front Page |
 Woman's Club To Donate "Story Time" Sculpture

|
02-24-2021 | Front Page |
 County Board Applauds Selection Of Glenn Sartorelli To Head DHHS

|
02-24-2021 | Front Page |
 Peshtigo Council To Meet March 2

|
02-24-2021 | Front Page |
 Water Treatment Program Discussed At Town Meeting

|
02-24-2021 | Front Page |
 Pound Village Board To Air Well Issues Feb. 26

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman Board May Restore 5-Day In-Person Classes For Upper Grades

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Wausaukee To Hold Zoning Change Hearing March 10

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 By 4 to 3 Vote Crivitz Board Keeps Masks For This Year

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Country Line Dancing Resumes at Equity

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Lena School Staff Spaghetti Supper

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman School District Pre-K Screening, Jr. K Registration

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 January Students of the Month at Crivitz Elem., Middle Schools

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 Crivitz Church Has Food and Fellowship to Go

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Wausaukee Lions Flower Sale, Bowling Tournament

|
02-24-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Silver Cliff Celebrates Centennial Aug. 12-14

|
02-24-2021 | Sports |
 Coleman Tops Crivitz for Third Time to Take Regional Title

|
02-24-2021 | Sports |
 Suring Falls to Athens in Sectional Semifinal

|
02-24-2021 | Sports |
 State Runner-up Cougars Fall in Final 33-32

|
02-24-2021 | Sports |
 Ice Shanty Removal Dates Approaching

|
02-24-2021 | Sports |
 Peshtigo Girls Softball In Need of Players

|
02-24-2021 | Perspectives |
 From our readers

|
02-24-2021 | Perspectives |
 From My Window

|
02-24-2021 | Perspectives |
 Country Cousin

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Marie R. Apple

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Tony F. Camp

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Jason S. Chaltry

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Dr. Richard R. Chaltry

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Judie Gowaski

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 William H. Howell

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Pauline R. Ireland

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Kenneth J. Kalafut

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Mitchell A. Keyport

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Carol J. Kobus

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Robert E. Kons

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Darlene M. Kostuch

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Mark R. Krzewina

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Ann L. Lemke

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Grace L. Meyers

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Sandra J. Michaud

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Evelyn Nelson

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Norma Parker

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 Alfred G. Polzin

|
02-24-2021 | Obituaries |
 William Sweeting

|
02-17-2021 | Front Page |
 Marinette Marine Breaks Ground For Largest Building Ever On Site

|
02-17-2021 | Front Page |
 Peshtigo School Board Hears PSI, Administration Reports

|
02-17-2021 | Front Page |
 Tyco/JCI Provides New Updates on PFAS Issue

|
02-17-2021 | Front Page |
 Marinette School Classes Going In-Person March 1

|
02-17-2021 | Front Page |
 Report To Chamber On The Fire Sesquicentennial, Kayak Dock

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman School District Pre-K Screening, Jr. K Registration

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Suring School Distant Learner Numbers Drop From 58 To 31

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 County Line Dancing Resumes at Equity

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 School Board To Consider Facilities, Masks, Prom

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 Middle Inlet Board OKs Purchase Of Fire Truck

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 Crivitz American Legion Gun Show March 13th

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Town of Wausaukee Sets Road Weight Limit Rules, Exceptions

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Parking On Boat Launch Road Remains Problem For Wagner

|
02-17-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Silver Cliff To Celebrate Centennial Aug. 12-14

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Area Teams Advance to Regional Second Round

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Regional Heart Breakers Leave Suring as Sole Survivor

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Boys & Girls Hockey Teams to Play for State Titles

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Whiting Wins Third Title; Casper Claims Silver

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Task Force Conducts Modified Marinette Realignment Review

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 Marinette Youth Baseball Online Registration Starts March 1st

|
02-17-2021 | Sports |
 PHS Alumni Scholarship Golf Outing July 16th

|
02-17-2021 | Perspectives |
 From My Window

|
02-17-2021 | Perspectives |
 From Our Readers...

|
02-17-2021 | Perspectives |
 Country Cousin

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Delores M. Cline

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Robert J. Collard

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Ruth A. Davey

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 James R. Derusha

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Gerald Elsner

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Melva Hetcher

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Susan K Meicht

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Darlene L. Szymusiak

|
02-17-2021 | Obituaries |
 Darlean J. Webb

|
02-10-2021 | Front Page |


|
02-10-2021 | |


|
02-10-2021 | Front Page |
 DNR Listening Session Provides PFAS Updates

|
02-10-2021 | Front Page |
 Tyco Announces Updates Of Recent Water Testing

|
02-10-2021 | Front Page |
 City of Peshtigo Partners With Historical Committee

|
02-10-2021 | Front Page |
 Mayor Genisot Gives State of City Address

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Ash Wednesday Service at Pound

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Annual Equity Craft, Vendor Fair June 19

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Coleman |
 Coleman School District Pre-K Screening, Jr. K Registration

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 Community Ed Offers Farmhouse Spring Wreath

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 High Falls Fish-O-Rama, Radar Run, Winterfest

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Crivitz |
 CBA Persons of Year Nominations Accepted

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Wausaukee Blood Drive is Feb. 15th

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Friends of Wausaukee Library Annual Fruit Sale

|
02-10-2021 | Community - Wausaukee |
 Religious Ed Students Bowl for St. Jude Hospital

|
02-10-2021 | Sports |
 Coleman Beats Crivitz, Stays Undefeated in M&O

|
02-10-2021 | Sports |
 WIAA Tournament Play Begins; Gillett Advances Over Crivitz

|
02-10-2021 | Sports |
 Coleman Wins Sectional; Advances to Team State

|
02-10-2021 | Sports |
 Individuals Compete for State Wrestling Titles This Weekend

|
02-10-2021 | Sports |
 DNR Publishes Sturgeon Spearing Season Forecast

|
02-10-2021 | Perspectives |
 From My Window

|
02-10-2021 | Perspectives |
 Country Cousin

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Marjorie A. Barley

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 William J. Bohan

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Mary M. Coddington

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Sue Flanner

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Mary Ann Gardon

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Donald E. Hayes Jr.

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Sandy R. Hendrickson

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Charlotte A. Hoffman

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Sue M. Jones

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Karen A. Konop

|
02-10-2021 | Obituaries |
 Joseph Krzewina Jr.

|
|
|
| |
|