space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* WIAA Crowns Four State Spring Baseball Champions
* Multiple Marines Awarded Spring Post-Season Honors
* Bulldogs Picked for Packerland Honors In Three Spring Sports
* Little River Hosts Fathers Day Scramble
* Marinette/Menominee Open Summer Seasons with Wins

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space

Oconto County Rejects Variance For B & D Dairy

Issue Date: May 24, 2017

A variance sought by B & D Dairy to construct a 12 million-gallon manure storage facility closer than 250 feet to the nearest property line off Hillcrest Road in the Town of Little River was denied by Oconto County Board at the conclusion of an hour-long formal appeal hearing on Thursday, May 18.

B & D Dairy is owned by Brian Lepianka and his wife, Danette Ossmann. Its main dairy cow operation is located in the Town of Grover in Marinette County. Manure from that farm would be hauled to property they own in the Town of Little River in winter to be stored in the proposed pit. In spring and summer it would be delivered by a hose system to fertilize fields on which they raise feed crops.

The narrow 14 to 15 County Board vote rejecting the variance came after nearly an hour of testimony and discussion at the board's regular monthly meeting on Thursday, May 18. There were no proposals to modify the variance conditions, although that was a third option.

The 14 supervisors who voted to support the variance as recommended by the LCC were Chair Lee Rymer, Elmer Ragen, Darrel Pagel, Dennis Kroll, Robert Pott, Al Stranz, Karl Ballestad, Jim Lacourciere, Buzz Kamke, Bill Grady Mary Lemen, Paul Bednarik, Richard Nelson, and Alan Sleeter. Supervisors Gary Frank and Ron Korzeniewski were absent.

Those opposed were supervisors Don Girardi, Chris Augustine, Vernon Zoeller, Diane Nichols, Robert Reinhart, Gerald Beekman, Rose Stellmacher, Melissa Wellens, Ken Linzmeyer, Greg Sekela, Doug McMahon, Ryan Wendt, Judith Buhrandt, Don Bartels Jr. and David Christianson.

Oconto County Conservationist Ken Dolata said County Board rejection of the variance does not mean the storage facility cannot be built on the Town of Little River acreage purchased by B & D Dairy for growing feed crops, but does mean it cannot be sited on the property exactly as planned, and in the spot the Land Conservation Committee (LCC) felt was the best location.

The variance had been approved by unanimous vote of the LCC in April, following a site visit. Provisions were that it be built no closer than 153 feet from the nearest property, with conditions that the landowner (B & D Dairy) install and maintain a safety fence around the storage facility and that emergency spill detention basins be constructed on the west side between the storage structure and stream and on the north and south sides of the driveways with a volume that would hold the contents of the largest semi tanker. Plans for these conditions were to be approved by the LCC division before installation. The property it would have been closest to is also owned by B & D Farms, but is separated from the main acreage by Hillcrest Road.

At its April 10 meeting at Little River Town Hall the committee had listened to public testimony, and 24 persons filled out public hearing appearance cards. Dolata had explained the ordinance and reasons for requesting the variance. Jennifer Keuning and Nicholas Coady of GHD Services, Inc. explained the variance requested on behalf of B & D Dairy and discussed some of the specifics and details for the planned storage facility and surrounding area. Committee vote granting the variance was six to zero.

After that vote, the LCC received 27 requests to appeal the variance. By County Ordinance, County Board is designated as the Appeals body to review the action taken by the LCC and could either affirm, reverse or modify the committee decision.

Corporation Counsel Cheryl Mick explained to County Board at the start of the formal appeal hearing that if the variance was rejected, B&D Dairy could either appeal to circuit court by seeking a writ of certiorari (which could leave the variance intact), or go back to the LCC for a permit without the variance.

Dolata said despite numerous objections from neighbors and town officials if B&D Dairy chooses to apply for the permit without the variance, his department will have to grant it if the plan meets all the ordinance requirements, and he believes it does.

He explained Oconto County has an ordinance through which anyone wanting to build an animal waste facility there must get a permit from the Land Conservation Department. Land Conservation staff and the committee first verify that the proposed facility meets all state and federal requirements. If it does, the permit must be granted. "The committee cannot refuse a permit if the project meets all the requirements," he repeated.

Dolata said ironically, the variance would have allowed the facility to be built closer to the lot line with the other parcel owned by B&D, but farther from its nearest actual neighbor, who was one of the objectors. Had the variance remained intact the pit would have been 153 feet from another property owned by B&D Dairy, but under separate deed because it is across the road. Now it must be 250 feet from that line, but will be almost 100 feet closer to one of the neighbors who appealed.

Dolata said part of the committee rationale in granting the variance was that the pit could be put deeper in the ground and moved toward the line with B & D's own property and 97 feet farther away from the neighbors to the south.

The main farm of the 7,000-head B & D Dairy operation is located in the Town of Grover in Marinette County. County Board was told plans are to haul manure from there to the storage pit in Little River mainly during winter months when roads are frozen. By means of a pipe line system, with no further trucking involved, manure from the pit will be used to fertilize feed crop fields at various times during the spring and summer.

To Dolata's knowledge, no public funds will be involved in building the B&D facility. He explained once over about 700 dairy cows, the state and federal governments consider the farm a "Confined Area Feed Operation" (CAFO), which must get a permit from the DNR to operate and is not eligible for any state or federal funds.

According to the B & D Dairy website, B and D Dairy is "a modern, family farm where cows and family are the focus....Owners Brian Lepianka and his wife, Danette Ossmann are the third generation to farm on the northeastern Wisconsin site of B and D Dairy. Their sons, Nathan and Reily, join them as the 4th generation....B an D Dairy works with 85 different families who own much of the 7000 acres of land they are able to use to produce corn silage and alfalfa for their 7500 animals....The dairy provides an income for the families of 35 employees who work to keep the cows milked, and ensure all animals are given the best nutrition and a clean, comfortable environment."

At the start of the County Board hearing, Mick explained the procedure, which she said does not happen very often. She said B&D Dairy was granted the variance, and GHD Engineering drew the design for them.

Persons objecting to the variance were entitled to deposit written evidence regarding their position, and appear in person. She said all County Board members had received copies of the complaints.

Main concerns expressed by neighbors centered on odors, loss of property values, damage to town roads, and possible contamination of groundwater should a spill or leak occur, or if manure was spread too heavily on fields.

Mick explained only those who had a complaint that their rights, duties or privileges were affected could appeal.

"We're here today to listen to you," Rymer assured everyone in the filled board room.

Dolata explained the proposed project and gave a brief history of the animal waste ordinance adopted in 2002 with input from a citizen's advisory committee.

He said the proposed project is to be a "satellite collector" for animal wastes from the main farm in Marinette County. It is to be a concrete lined put that will be filled in winter with manure to be spread on fields in spring.

He said with the variance, because of elevations dikes around the pit could be four to five feet high instead of 10 to 12 feet, and the pit would be 97 feet from the nearest neighbor. The committee felt having it built into the ground also would be safer.

Dolata said the DNR does not have setback requirements for these facilities, but does make sure concrete meet specifications and verifies that the pit is the proper distance from the water table. The location allowed by the variance is the highest elevation available on the property.

First opponent to testify was Robert Desjarlais, who said he had been asked by Little River residents to represent them at the hearing. He has been Town Chair for 8 years and member of the town board for 10 years.

He said he had been at the first meeting, "and it was kind of a hot topic in our township." There was a petition with about 100 signatures, and 60 to 70 people attended the hearing, at which he felt the public was disregarded. "We did get off the subject," he admitted.

He said during the on-site visit there were perhaps 25 to 30 people waiting at the gate, but the committee drove past them and went to the proposed pit location without inviting them. "I have never seen an onsite visit done in that fashion," he declared.

He said Little River lies in a protected watershed, there is a navigable stream on the property, gas lines are on two sides, and a town road on one side. He felt the variance was requested because without it, there is absolutely no room to expand the pit. With it there is.

He said it is the opinion of Little River residents that the reason for the variance was to save money for the owner, "and you cannot grant a variance for economic gain."

Desjarlais said he was on the Plan Committee when the ordinance was adopted, and "Our main goal was to allow agriculture to function while protecting the environment."

Mick interrupted to ask him what adverse effect the variance had on him or the people he was speaking for.

He replied mainly there are concerns about groundwater quality and property values.

Mick said there is no evidence that the groundwater quality will be affected, "but you believe that (concern) affects property values?" Desjarlais said that was true.

Next called was Doug Allen, who lives in Little Suamico and represents the Farm Service Agency on the LCC. Allen said he does not live in Little River, but does represent the LCC and is in favor of the variance.

Next speaker against the variance was Richard Kloes, who has the farm just south of the proposed pit. "What is going to happen with smell when they put 12 million gallons of manure in a pit 1,000 feet from my home... How can you not smell it?... When you agitate manure gasses and odors come out!" He said there also is a 10-acre wildlife area nearby, "and when this escapes, what's going to happen to the wildlife?" There are also three wells on his farm, "and if they get contaminated, that's an expense to me!"

Randy Larmay, who owns land kitty corner and across the road from fields where the manure will be spread was called on next.

He said B & D Farms bought 600 acres for crops and felt the land couldn't handle the manure from a pit that large. He said 12 million gallons, divided by 600 acres, means they will be spreading 20,000 gallons per acre, "and the land can't handle that much!" He also said manure hauling, at 6,000 gallons a load, will damage the down roads, and also will be making a mess. He declared there should be a limit on the number of animals one farm can have, and said with milk prices so low, there's no demand for it right now anyway. "I bet Kewaunee County wishes they had decided differently," he concluded.

Coady, speaking for GHD Services, Inc. and B & D Farm, said the pit can be built on the site with or without the variance, but placing it on the highest elevation would reduce the height of the berms. He added the higher berms do not cost much more than the lower ones. He explained B & D Farm had wanted to combine the two parcels it owns, but could not because Hillcrest Road is a dividing line. Their design keeps the pit set back 300 feet from the high water area.

Part of the reason for the pit is to prevent damage to town roads. Manure can be hauled in winter when the road base is frozen, and then be available in spring when it can be hosed to fields where it is needed, with no trucking involved at sensitive times.

He said just because the pit will hold 12 million gallons doesn't mean it will be full, nor does it mean that the manure will be spread all at one time. Spreading will be done during the growing season as needed.

Stellmacher commented 12 million gallons equals more than 2,000 semi loads of manure, which would have "quite an impact on town and county roads." She noted there are no cows on the Little River property, "so all the manure is imported from Marinette County." She suggested they should talk to the DNR about a rule against moving manure from one county to another.

Nichols too wanted to know why the manure is not being taken care of in Marinette County, where it is produced.

Dolata explained B&D Farm is a large operation, and he bought the property in Little River to raise feed for the cattle he has at his main operation in Marinette County. Dolata felt county lines were not a consideration. Using the manure will help the farm use less artificial fertilizer, Dolata said. There is no rule about moving manure from county to county, but there are rules on how heavily it can be spread, and where it can be put.

Sekela questioned lack of emergency barriers between the pit and the creek, and Dolata said the variance does require that, in addition to emergency pits on either side of the driveway big enough to contain the spillage in case a semi rolls over.

Bednarik asked if towns have a say in the pit location, and Dolata said they do not. He confirmed again that the pit can be built without the variance.

Sleeter noted in the past the DNR regulated the amount of manure that could be applied per acre, and Dolata said it still does. The owner has to follow a crop management plan filed with the Land Conservation Department.

Members of the LCC were asked to speak. Kroll and Allen said they all thought the hill wold be the best place for the pit.

Grady said he worked that land and is concerned about the water. He said the first thing the Lepiankas did when they moved in was cap the wells.

Dolata said nutrient management rules require no spreading within 300 feet of any well, but was unable to say why the wells were capped.

Wendt, who himself operates a dairy farm, asked if Oconto County ordinances say anything about satellite manure storage, and Dolata the rules are the same for any manure storage facility. Wendt said farm operations that include homes and buildings for cattle, equipment, etc., bring in a lot of tax revenue, but from this type of operation the county gets very little. "I believe Oconto County should quickly put together some restrictions," he declared. He said the manure from a big dairy facility "is a huge deal!" He reminded Dolata that last month their committee came in for money for some lake quality work, "and this is very contrary to that!"

Mick said from a legal perspective, "I don't know that because you live outside the county you cannot use land you own here like anybody else."

Augustine asked if all the farm permits are up to date, and Dolata said if they were not the DNR would not approve this application.

Kloes said on the day the committee visited the pit site he and others were waiting at the gate, but no one invited them to come up there. He said there are two dug wells on the B & D property that have not been capped yet, and predicted disaster if manure gets into the two dug wells on the property that have not been capped yet.

Vote then was called, with the 14 to 15 rejection of the committee's decision to grant the variance.

After the hearing, Dolata said his committee prefers manure spreading with hoses and knifing the materials into the ground. He said farmers can pump manure five miles with hoses, which eliminates need for a lot of heavy truck traffic


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
06-22-2018Sports
WIAA Crowns Four State Spring Baseball Champions

06-22-2018
Peshtigo High School softball team members, Madi Martin and Shae Tonn were chosen to play in the Division 2/3 game held on June 12

06-21-2018Front Page
Marinette County Breakfast on the Farm is June 24th

06-21-2018Front Page
Kass Resigns County Finance Director Post

06-21-2018Front Page
Peshtigo Police Chief Resigns, Moving Back To Michigan

06-21-2018Front Page
Infrastructure Committee Wants To Move Back To Peshtigo Shop

06-21-2018Front Page
Kiosk At Riverside Cemetery To Help Identify Grave Sites

06-21-2018Community - Coleman
CHS 1943-65 Class Reunion is July 15th

06-21-2018Community - Coleman
Car Show Vendor Deadline June 25

06-21-2018Community - Coleman
Library To Host Ice Cream Social

06-21-2018Community - Coleman
Coleman Youth Basketball Camp

06-21-2018Community - Crivitz
Crivitz VFW Post 2063 Meets

06-21-2018Community - Crivitz
Ice Cream Social at Crivitz June 28

06-21-2018Community - Crivitz
Camp Bird Event is June 20-22

06-21-2018Community - Crivitz
M&M Area Foundation Helps Fund School Supplies

06-21-2018Community - Wausaukee
Jose Honored as Legionnaire of Year

06-21-2018Community - Wausaukee
Athelstane/Silver Cliff Legion Post 66 To Meet June 23

06-21-2018Community - Wausaukee
Harvest Dinner at Presbyterian Church

06-21-2018Community - Wausaukee
Blood Drive at Silver Cliff Rescue

06-21-2018Obituaries
Shirley J. Behnke

06-21-2018Obituaries
Eunice R. Borst

06-21-2018Obituaries
Betty M. Dettloff

06-21-2018Obituaries
June E. Diercks

06-21-2018Obituaries
Elizabeth L. Downs

06-21-2018Obituaries
Edith Franzen

06-21-2018Obituaries
Edna M. Garon

06-21-2018Obituaries
Mary Louise Gauld

06-21-2018Obituaries
Thomas A. Gilligan

06-21-2018Obituaries
Mary C. Gocht

06-21-2018Obituaries
Peggy Madden

06-21-2018Obituaries
Gerald F. Wescher

06-21-2018Perspectives
Country Cousin

06-21-2018Perspectives
From My Window

06-21-2018Perspectives
From our Readers

06-21-2018Sports
Multiple Marines Awarded Spring Post-Season Honors

06-21-2018Sports
Bulldogs Picked for Packerland Honors In Three Spring Sports

06-21-2018
Martin/Tonn Play in WFSCA All Star Game

06-21-2018Sports
Little River Hosts Fathers Day Scramble

06-14-2018Front Page
Coleman Annexes Property For Cheese Factory Project

06-14-2018Front Page
Pound Fireman's Picnic, Car Show Both In June

06-14-2018Front Page
Environmental Groups Pledge To Continue Back Forty Fight

06-14-2018Front Page
PFAS Found At Tyco Stanton Street Facility

06-14-2018Front Page
Grover Residents Advised To Keep Fire Signs Visible

06-14-2018Community - Coleman
Renovation Tour On Coleman School Board June 18 Agenda

06-14-2018Community - Coleman
Village Pound Car Show is June 30th

06-14-2018Community - Coleman
Continue to Feature Cougar Walls of Fame

06-14-2018Community - Coleman
4th Annual Craft, Vendor Fair at Equity Park June 16

06-14-2018Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Junior High Students Attain Honors

06-14-2018Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Legion Run for Recovery

06-14-2018
Ice Cream Social at Crivitz June 28

06-14-2018Community - Crivitz
Monthly CPR Class at Crivitz Clinic

06-14-2018Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Announces 4th Quarter Honor Roll

06-14-2018Community - Wausaukee
Alee Aragon Addresses Auxiliary

06-14-2018Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Back to School Program Receives $3,000

06-14-2018Community - Wausaukee
WBA Sponsors Farmers Market

06-14-2018Sports
Marinette/Menominee Open Summer Seasons with Wins

06-14-2018
Area Golfers Receive GCAW Academic All State Honors

06-14-2018Sports
Five High Schools Claim WIAA State Softball Titles

06-14-2018Sports
Busy Season For Marinette Parks & Rec & Public Works

06-14-2018Perspectives
From My Window

06-14-2018Perspectives
Country Cousin

06-14-2018Perspectives
From Our Readers

06-07-2018Sports
WIAA Softball State Tourney Starts June 7

06-07-2018Sports
Area Golfers Battle Through Tough State Course

06-07-2018Sports
Peshtigo's Rauch Captures D2 State Pole Vault Title

06-07-2018Sports
Coleman/Wausaukee Bow Out In Sectionals

06-07-2018Perspectives
From Our Readers

06-07-2018Perspectives
Country Cousin

06-07-2018Perspectives
From My Window

06-07-2018Obituaries
Richard L. Dantinne

06-07-2018Obituaries
Mildred Donlevy 

06-07-2018Obituaries
Clara (Wasmund) Druckrey

06-07-2018Obituaries
John F. Egofske

06-07-2018Obituaries
Dixie K. Gard

06-07-2018Obituaries
Lila M. Hallada

06-07-2018Obituaries
Myron C. Klika

06-07-2018Obituaries
Donald D. Kroening

06-07-2018Obituaries
Kent W. Lantow

06-07-2018Obituaries
John W. Lesniak

06-07-2018Obituaries
Marsha A. Lindgren

06-07-2018Obituaries
Beth M. Mireau

06-07-2018Obituaries
Bonnie R. Berton-Neumeyer

06-07-2018Obituaries
Nancy J. Prange

06-07-2018Obituaries
Bruce E. Ranzinger

06-07-2018Obituaries
Ellen M. Raygo

06-07-2018Obituaries
Kathryn Schahczinski

06-07-2018Obituaries
Russell L. Schwartz

06-07-2018Obituaries
Kenneth J. VanDreel

06-07-2018Obituaries
John P. Wingers

06-07-2018Obituaries
Leonard F. Wirkus

06-07-2018Community - Wausaukee
Church Rummage Sale/Cook Out

06-07-2018Community - Wausaukee
SC Fire-Rescue to Plan Picnic

06-07-2018Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Class of 1988 Reunion on Aug. 18

06-07-2018Community - Crivitz
Ice Cream Social at Crivitz June 28

06-07-2018Community - Crivitz
Meeting for Girl Scouts at Crivitz

06-07-2018Community - Crivitz
Woman's Club Pop-Up Sale

06-07-2018Community - Coleman
Village Pound Car Show is June 30th

06-07-2018Community - Coleman
Pound Fire Picnic Dates June 15-16

06-07-2018Community - Coleman
Coleman Utility Board To Meet

06-07-2018Community - Coleman
Coleman Schools List Summer Office Hours

06-07-2018Front Page
New Brazeau Building Honors Elizabeth Washebek

06-07-2018Front Page
Final Permit Issued For Back Forty Mine

06-07-2018Front Page
Peshtigo Council Approves 1% Hike In Water Rates

06-07-2018Front Page
Late Season Snow Blamed For City Recreation Issues

06-07-2018Front Page
Town Peshtigo Airs Road, Billing Issues

05-31-2018Perspectives
From My Window

05-31-2018Sports
Rangers/Badgers Face Off in Regional Final Today

05-31-2018Sports
Rangers Are Last Team Standing on Tournament Trail

05-31-2018Sports
Area Athletes Head To State Meet In LaCrosse

05-31-2018Sports
Peshtigo Takes Perfect Record To State

05-31-2018Perspectives
Country Cousin

05-31-2018Obituaries
Earl J. Alsteen

05-31-2018Obituaries
Elizabeth L. Anglehart

05-31-2018Obituaries
James A. Benesh

05-31-2018Obituaries
Paul R. Berntson

05-31-2018Obituaries
Dale R. Borneman

05-31-2018Obituaries
Robert F. Brown, Jr.

05-31-2018Obituaries
Norman Buhrandt

05-31-2018Obituaries
Roberta C. Couillard

05-31-2018Obituaries
Richard Deschaine

05-31-2018Obituaries
Karen and Dennis Fry

05-31-2018Obituaries
Raymond A. Gorman

05-31-2018Obituaries
Glenn G. Harris

05-31-2018Obituaries
Charles W. Hatton 

05-31-2018Obituaries
Stella M. Horvath

05-31-2018Obituaries
Patricia A. Johnston

05-31-2018Obituaries
Sandra S. Kasik

05-31-2018Obituaries
Carol L. Klein

05-31-2018Obituaries
Arlie K. Manning

05-31-2018Obituaries
Patrice L. Messenger

05-31-2018Obituaries
Laurie Nicklaus

05-31-2018Obituaries
Helen M. Peterson

05-31-2018Obituaries
Rita Peterson

05-31-2018Obituaries
Jacqueline Rudolph

05-31-2018Obituaries
Gertrude Tetzlaff

05-31-2018Obituaries
William M. Thierling

05-31-2018Obituaries
Joy M. Van Hecke

05-31-2018Obituaries
Daniel D. VanHoff

05-31-2018Obituaries
Ramon G. Varrientos

05-31-2018Obituaries
Leonard J. Williams

05-31-2018Community - Wausaukee
Seven Red Cross Scholarship Winners

05-31-2018Community - Wausaukee
 Wausuakee Lions Big Cash Raffle

05-31-2018Community - Wausaukee
WBA Farmers Market New Location This Year

05-31-2018Community - Crivitz
Sports Awards Winners At Crivitz High School

05-31-2018
NE WI Kids Fishing Outing July 7 at Laona

05-31-2018Community - Crivitz
Lions Golf Scramble at Crivitz June 2nd

05-31-2018Community - Crivitz
De Smidt's Awards Four Scholarships

05-31-2018Community - Coleman
Coleman Village Board June 4

05-31-2018Community - Coleman
4th Annual Craft, Vendor Fair at Equity Park June 16

05-31-2018Community - Coleman
Pound Fire Dept. Picnic July 15-16


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you think the Green Bay Packers will make it to the Super Bowl this year.
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2018
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites