space
space
Peshtigo Times
space
space
space
Perspectives
* Country Cousin
space
space
Sports Shorts
* Jack Farley Is TimesLand 2017-18 Top Athlete
* Chloe Gruszynski Tops Area Athlete List for 2017-18
* Cougars Claim Extra Inning Victory Over Niagara 8-7
* WIAA Winter Team Tournament Sportsmanship Awards Selected
* Area Athletes Get Back on The Track

space
Peshtigo Fire
space
e-Edition
Now Available
For more information
click here
dot
THE CITY REBORN FROM THE ASHES OF AMERICA'S MOST DISASTROUS FOREST FIRE
space
dot
space

Court Battles Continue Over Back Forty Mine

Issue Date: August 9, 2018

Efforts continue on several fronts to halt development of the controversial Back Forty Mine near the banks of the Menominee River in Stephenson Township, Mich., about 15 miles upstream from the cities of Marinette and Menominee and the mouth of the river into the waters of Green Bay and Lake Michigan.

On June 4 of this year Michigan Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ) announced that it had issued a wetlands permit for the mine, which was the fourth and final permit required before Aquila could begin the project.  The MDEQ had previously issued mining, air, and surface water discharge permits.

In U.S. Eastern District Court in Green Bay on Wednesday, Aug. 1, Judge William C. Griesbach heard arguments for and against issuance of permits for the mine. Judge Griesbach is considering the case, and is not expected to announce his decision for several weeks.

Last Wednesday's Federal Court hearing was just one of the steps in settling a lawsuit brought by the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin against the Federal Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for what they claim was an improper delegation of their permitting responsibilities to the State of Michigan.

Since that hearing, separate petitions for Contested Case Hearings in the State of Michigan have been filed with MDEQ by the locally based non-profit Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc., and the Menominee Tribe of Indians. Both are challenging MDEQ's decision to grant Aquila Resources the wetlands permit.

Opponents of the sulfide mine say the operation will adversely affect wetlands next to the Menominee River and local groundwater on both sides of the river, as well as the river itself and possibly Lake Michigan, as well as adversely impacting numerous sites of cultural and historic significance to the Menominees.

Represented by Earthjustice and tribal attorneys, the Menominees filed suit in January of 2018, charging that the federal agencies have abandoned their obligation under the Clean Water Act to exercise jurisdiction over wetland permits for the mine.

In court on Aug. 1, attorneys for EPA, the Corps of Engineers and Aquila Resources, Inc. asked that the Tribe's lawsuit be dismissed, and decision on that request is pending.

Attorneys representing the tribe argued that by allowing the State of Michigan to oversee what should have been a federal permitting process, the federal agencies violated requirements of the Clean Water Act.

Those representing the Menominee Tribe's interests include Earthjustice Attorney Janette Brimmer; Attorney Lindzey Spice, for the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin, and Melissa Cook, intergovernmental affairs manager for the Menominee Tribe of Wisconsin. 

 Menominee Tribal Chairman Doug Cox and other members of the Tribal Legislature attended the U.S. District Court proceedings in Green Bay.

There has been strong local opposition to the mine, particularly from the Wisconsin side of the Menominee River, which is also the border between Michigan and Wisconsin.

County boards and various municipalities in Marinette, Oconto, Menominee and several other Wisconsin counties overwhelmingly passed resolutions opposing the mine.

On Thursday, Aug. 2, Dale Burie, president of the Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc., announced that his organization had filed the contested Case Haring petition, challenging MDEQ's decision to grant Aquila Resources the wetlands permit.

In a news release announcing the petition, Burrie declared, "There has never been a metallic sulfide mine that successfully avoided polluting area water supplies. Since the Menominee River is the Boundary Water between Michigan and Wisconsin, metallic sulfide mining near the river has the grave potential to impact surface and groundwater resources on both sides of the river and damage water quality of the municipal water supplies for the cities of Menominee, Michigan and Marinette, Wisconsin, which in turn threatens human health. The fact that these risks remain unevaluated is evident when looking at 30 pages of conditions that are to be completed before startup."

"In addition to water quality, degrading the Menominee River affects fish and other aquatic life, wildlife, tourism, property values of taxpayers on both sides of the river, and disturbs the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin's ancient burial grounds," the news release continues.

Burrie's home borders the Menominee River on the Wisconsin side, in the Wagner area north of Marinette. He said the Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) non-profit corporation that consists solely of volunteers; there are no salaries.

Many Coalition members live directly across the river from the proposed mine site.

"The Coalition represents the interests of individuals and groups concerned about the effects of the proposed Back Forty mine," Burrie said. "The Coalition echoes the opposition voiced by groups such as River Alliance of Wisconsin, the Sierra Club, Freshwater Future, the Front 40 Group, numerous additional environmental organizations and municipalities, as well as thousands of concerned citizens living in Michigan and Wisconsin, in opposition to the proposed Back Forty project."

The Coalition to SAVE the Menominee River, Inc. is represented by environmental attorneys Ted A. Warpinski of Davis & Kuelthau in Green Bay, Wisconsin, and Bruce Wallace of Hooper Hathaway in Ann Arbor, Michigan.

In a news release issued on Monday, Aug. 6, the Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin announced that on Friday, Aug. 3 it had filed its own petition for a contested case hearing on the DEQ's issuance of the wetlands permit.

Tribal attorneys and Earthjustice attorneys contend granting the permit was contrary to Michigan law and happened in spite of written objections of its own Water Resources Division. The petition argues that the application left out critical information on the river and wetlands system, and is based on promises that the developer would provide information down the road."

Cox, Menominee Tribe chairman, said their tribe had lived in the mine area since time immemorial and the operation will affect areas of historical interest to them, including burial grounds, agricultural sites and ceremonial sites. They also say in its decision to issue the wetlands permit the MDEQ had ignored objections from its own Michigan tribes and members of the public.

The contested case proceedings are reportedly to be handled by an administrative law judge in Michigan.


Recent stories, opinions and photos

Issue Date Department Headline
04-18-2019Front Page


04-18-2019Front Page
Town Of Middle Inlet Has New Town Clerk/Treasurer

04-18-2019Front Page
Peshtigo Council Denies Sewer Rate Reduction For BPM, Inc.

04-18-2019Front Page
County Board Supports Anti-Marijuana Resolution

04-18-2019Front Page
Name Bantes "Honorary Bulldog" For Her Crossing Guard Heroism

04-18-2019Front Page
Herman Pottratz Takes Over As Town of Peshtigo Chairman

04-18-2019Sports
Jack Farley Is TimesLand 2017-18 Top Athlete

04-18-2019Sports
Chloe Gruszynski Tops Area Athlete List for 2017-18

04-18-2019Sports
Cougars Claim Extra Inning Victory Over Niagara 8-7

04-18-2019Sports
WIAA Winter Team Tournament Sportsmanship Awards Selected

04-18-2019Sports
Area Athletes Get Back on The Track

04-18-2019Sports
Bulldogs Get Past Clippers With Late Inning Rally

04-18-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman-Pound Lions Honor 3 State Champs

04-18-2019Community - Coleman
Pound Woman's Club To Celebrate 100 Years

04-18-2019Community - Coleman
ADRC Program at Coleman Library

04-18-2019Community - Crivitz
LNRD Board Meeting April 18

04-18-2019Community - Crivitz
PTSD Run Sponsor Donations for Veterans

04-18-2019Community - Crivitz
Medicare Talk at Crivitz Apr. 30

04-18-2019Community - Crivitz
Dry Hootch at Crivitz May 15

04-18-2019Community - Wausaukee
Northwoods Church Easter Service

04-18-2019Community - Wausaukee
Voices of Peace Easter at Athelstane

04-18-2019Community - Wausaukee
Presbyterian Church Bake Sale May 10th

04-18-2019Community - Wausaukee
SC Fire, Rescue Meeting May 13th

04-18-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin

04-18-2019Perspectives
From Our Readers

04-18-2019Perspectives
From My Window

04-18-2019Obituaries
Alice Behnke

04-18-2019Obituaries
Carol J. Bohan

04-18-2019Obituaries
Jerome Degayner

04-18-2019Obituaries
Elizabeth A. Driskill

04-18-2019Obituaries
Judy A. Ehmer

04-18-2019Obituaries
Bernard J. Fatla

04-18-2019Obituaries
Mary A. Gerisch

04-18-2019Obituaries
Charles Gretzinger

04-18-2019Obituaries
Marie P. Hanson

04-18-2019Obituaries
Helen E. Herr

04-18-2019Obituaries
Pauline H. Jakups

04-18-2019Obituaries
Rebecca J. Larmay

04-18-2019Obituaries
Janice M. Lehman

04-18-2019Obituaries
Deirdre Linder

04-18-2019Obituaries
Mary Meyer

04-18-2019Obituaries
Joan E. Miller

04-18-2019Obituaries
Myrna M. Miller

04-18-2019Obituaries
Norma J. Pecor

04-18-2019Obituaries
Naida C. Philipps

04-18-2019Obituaries
Alfred Ouellette

04-18-2019Obituaries
Thomas O. Rastall

04-18-2019Obituaries
Maynard J. Robbins, Jr.

04-18-2019Obituaries
Thomas P. Roland

04-18-2019Obituaries
Helen M. Schanke

04-18-2019Obituaries
Katharina Schwabe

04-18-2019Obituaries
Gerald Thirion

04-18-2019Obituaries
George Tomek

04-18-2019Obituaries
Barbara E. Valentine

04-18-2019Obituaries
Helen J. Zeh

04-18-2019Obituaries
Mark A. Zenil

04-11-2019Front Page
Two Graduate From Drug Court April 1

04-11-2019Front Page
City Postpones BPM Rate Request To April 16 Meeting

04-11-2019Front Page
County May Consider Marijuana Referendum

04-11-2019Front Page
Marinette Council Okays Walmart Liquor Change

04-11-2019Front Page
Coleman School Renovation Bids Approved, Work Starts

04-11-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wausaukee Jr/Sr High 3rd Quarter Honor Roll Listed

04-11-2019Community - Wausaukee
Card Parties Benefit Wagner Fire Department

04-11-2019Community - Wausaukee
Walk Through Nature Talk at Wausaukee

04-11-2019Community - Wausaukee
Easter Egg Hunt April 20

04-11-2019Community - Crivitz
Crivitz High School Lists 3rd Quarter Honor Roll

04-11-2019Community - Crivitz
Country Jam at Crivitz April 12

04-11-2019Community - Crivitz
Woman's Club To Meet April 18

04-11-2019Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Legion Meeting May 15

04-11-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman-Pound Lions Club Brunch April 14

04-11-2019Community - Coleman
Cancel Good Friday Fish Fry

04-11-2019Community - Coleman
Coleman Reunion for Classes of 1943-1965

04-11-2019Community - Coleman
Craft, Vendor Show at Equity June 15

04-11-2019Sports
Area Baseball Teams Off To Good Start

04-11-2019Sports
Marines Take Two From Truckers at Home

04-11-2019Sports
Area Outdoor Track & Field Season Gets Underway

04-11-2019Sports
Chronic Wasting Disease Increase During 2018 Surveillance Season

04-11-2019Perspectives
From Our Readers

04-11-2019Perspectives
From My Window

04-11-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin

04-11-2019Obituaries
Phyllis C. Beaudo

04-11-2019Obituaries
Harold Broderick

04-11-2019Obituaries
Donna M. Buelteman

04-11-2019Obituaries
Diane Chatlosh

04-11-2019Obituaries
Barbara A. Drake

04-11-2019Obituaries
Milford L. Eberly

04-11-2019Obituaries
Judy A. Ehmer

04-11-2019Obituaries
Mary A. Erdman

04-11-2019Obituaries
Shirley A. Fick

04-11-2019Obituaries
Diane R. Flynn

04-11-2019Obituaries
Muriel J. Gilbert

04-11-2019Obituaries
Ruth M. Hecht

04-11-2019Obituaries
Robert L. Helm

04-11-2019Obituaries
Kathleen L. Hemingway

04-11-2019Obituaries
Russell G. Kamps

04-11-2019Obituaries
Richard Kapla

04-11-2019Obituaries
LaVerne H. Kufner

04-11-2019Obituaries
Helen P. Kruse

04-11-2019Obituaries
Janice M. Lehman

04-11-2019Obituaries
Alexander J. Maxwell

04-11-2019Obituaries
John G. Rupple

04-11-2019Obituaries
John L. Seaborg

04-11-2019Obituaries
Judy Ann Shields 

04-11-2019Obituaries
Mary A. Smit

04-11-2019Obituaries
Shirley A. St. Pierre

04-11-2019Obituaries
Robert J. Steffen

04-11-2019Obituaries
Jon Stewart

04-11-2019Obituaries
Donald E. Vandermuss

04-11-2019Obituaries
Cathy Volm

04-11-2019Obituaries
Charles H. Weber

04-11-2019Obituaries
Betsy Werner

04-04-2019Obituaries
Albert P. Behrens

04-04-2019Obituaries
David M. Bloch

04-04-2019Obituaries
Eugene A. Dubey

04-04-2019Obituaries
Morton R. Gentz

04-04-2019Obituaries
Clare M. Helnik.

04-04-2019Obituaries
Eugene J. Homan

04-04-2019Obituaries
Delmar O. Kubitz

04-04-2019Obituaries
Elaine K. Lacasse

04-04-2019Obituaries
Bernice L. Laduron

04-04-2019Obituaries
Patrick D. Pichette

04-04-2019Obituaries
Janis Porfilio

04-04-2019Obituaries
Shirley G. Richardson

04-04-2019Obituaries
Lucille Rondeau

04-04-2019Obituaries
Robert L. Schroth

04-04-2019Obituaries
Gerald D. Shepherd

04-04-2019Obituaries
Agnes C. Skrzypinski

04-04-2019Obituaries
Robert J. Steffen

04-04-2019Obituaries
Nancy D. Strem

04-04-2019Obituaries
Mary J. Tadisch

04-04-2019Obituaries
Daniel J. Trinko

04-04-2019Obituaries
Robert J. Wolford

04-04-2019Perspectives
Country Cousin

04-04-2019Perspectives
From My Window

04-04-2019Perspectives
From our readers

04-04-2019Sports
Kralovetz's Norway Title Adds to Guitar Collection

04-04-2019Sports
Lady Marines Take Top Spot at Spartan Invite

04-04-2019Sports
Bulldogs Come From Behind to Beat Blue Devils 6-5

04-04-2019Sports
Blue Devils Use Long Ball to Nip Bulldogs 7-5

04-04-2019Community - Wausaukee
Post 66 to Meet April 6

04-04-2019Community - Wausaukee
Athelstane Women Easter Breakfast

04-04-2019Community - Wausaukee
Lions Annual Flower Sale

04-04-2019Community - Wausaukee
Wagner Board Holds Special Meet For Bills

04-04-2019Community - Crivitz
Middle Inlet To Meet April 11th

04-04-2019Community - Crivitz
Dry Hootch Comes to Crivitz

04-04-2019Community - Crivitz
Crivitz Library Open House Apr. 10

04-04-2019Community - Crivitz
CBA Egg Hunt Apr. 20

04-04-2019Community - Coleman
Library Program on Rhubarb, Asparagus

04-04-2019Community - Coleman
Craft, Vendor Show at Equity June 15

04-04-2019Community - Coleman
Pancake Brunch in Coleman on April 4


space
Peshtigo Times
WEB Poll!
Do you think Wisconsin should legalize marijuana?
space Yes
No
Undecided
space
TO VOTE CLICK
YES, NO or UNDECIDED

Suggest a Question
space .
space
FRONT
space
.
space
CLASSIFIEDS
space
.
space
COMMUNITY
space
.
space
GUEST BOOK
space
.
space
NEWS
space
.
space
OBITS
space
.
space
PERSPECTIVES
space
.
space
SPORTS
space
.
space
SUBSCRIBE
space
.
space
.
space
PESHTIGO FIRE
space
.
space
CUSTOM PRINTING
space
.
space
TIMES' SAVER
space
.
space
Click for Peshtigo, Wisconsin Forecast
FORECAST
space
Quick...
News or Ad Search
Enter News key words.
Enter Ad key words.



Peshtigo Times
841 Maple St
PO Box 187
Peshtigo, WI 54157
Phone: 715-582-4541
Email:
News@
PeshtigoTimes.com

space
Fax: 715-582-4662
© 2000-2019
All right reserved
space
Powered by
WEB Media
Interactive
COMMUNITY
WEB sites